Carmel FC takes pride in developing all of our players towards their goals and dreams. A number of our alumni have gone on to play in college. The following list represents players that spent time in our club. Some played their whole youth experience with us. Others spent part of their youth experience with us. All are our alumni.
| Player |
Birthyear |
College/University |
|
| Reese McDaniel | 1999 | Anderson University |  |
| Matthew Skaar | 1999 | Indiana University - Indianapolis |  |
| Grey Collins | 2001 | DePauw University |  |
| Catherine Parisi | 2001 | Holy Cross College |  |
| Emma Antoine | 2002 | Indiana University - Indianapolis |
|
| Brooke Bailey | 2002 | Western Michigan University |  |
| Henry Giesel | 2002 | Wabash College |  |
| Caroline Shepherd | 2002 | Huntington University |  |
| Erin Baker | 2003 | Wright State University |  |
| Ellie Cirrincione | 2003 | Huntington University |  |
| Dalton Grubbs | 2003 | Anderson University |  |
| Isabel Meyers | 2003 | Stephens College |  |
| Keston Jacobi | 2003 | Huntington University |  |
| Sophie Shepherd | 2004 | Huntington University |  |
| Itay Adi | 2005 | University of St. Francis |  |
| Aubree Empie | 2005 | DePauw University |  |
| Landon Huber | 2005 | Wabash College |  |
| Madison Shields | 2005 | DePauw University |  |
| JD Slivinski | 2005 | University of St. Francis |  |